That style of shoe, heavy straps, esp around ankle, accentuates that impression. I don't care for those clodhoppers (the shoe) but many women love that look.

I don't see any major or catastrophic issues to justify the lowest possible rating. If it's strictly a personal style preference, in the absence of medical defect or unusual malformation, I'd usually rate 3 stars. My 3 star rating covers female feet that are not my style as well as generic or average female feet that would not cause me to look away or turn down if offered. These feet are at least 3 stars, maybe 4 stars the way I see it.

Yes. https://youtu.be/xMmlrrsNhVs

Congratulations to them.